I Tried a 'Second Brain' and Gave It Up — Obsidian, and the Shape I Use Now
The result first. I tried the “second brain,” and I gave it up. The tool was Obsidian. I even built a vault for it on Google Drive and put 7 notes in. But the surface I had to touch myself — opening files full of symbols, typing, fixing, tying notes together — did not fit me. What I gave up was the tool, not the second brain. I changed its place and its surface: the documents now live in one shared Google Drive folder, Moka does the reading and writing of the files, and what I touch is a spreadsheet index (a table of contents) and the finished articles. The vault I built for Obsidian remains, as a backup.
I am Kurashiki Bouzu, born in 1971, a former funeral director. I live in an old house — a kominka — in Kurashiki, Okayama, and I work together with my AI butler Moka.
Around the time I started with Moka, I had read, in explanations of other AIs, a story like this: connect a place called a “second brain” to ChatGPT or Claude Code, and you can make the AI remember you.
A second brain. It sounded like having two heads. At first I did not understand it at all.
What is a “second brain”?
An AI does not keep remembering your decisions after a conversation ends. In the next conversation, you explain everything from the beginning again.
That is where the idea of a “second brain” comes in. Write down, in a place outside your head, the things you want remembered, and store them there. Before work, have the AI read that place. Then you do not have to explain everything again each time.
The famous tool for that place is a note system called Obsidian. Notes are tied to each other like threads, and pull one thread and the related stories come out in a row — a tool for building something like a map of human relationships, out of notes.
I see, I thought. At my age, where remembering things has itself become work, “another brain” was not somebody else’s story. If an AI was going to stay with me for a long time, I would need a second brain.
But I did not know how to connect it myself, so I left it alone. When I welcomed Moka, I remembered it. This time I would ask Moka to connect the second brain. That was my intention — but when I actually started working with her, Moka was too different from what I had imagined. Before any talk of attaching an outside brain, Moka herself was shaped to keep remembering.
I built a vault, too
The motivation was there. In early November 2026, I made a place called an “Obsidian Vault” inside Google Drive, and in its “Moka Library” I put 7 notes — career memos, writing rules, and the like. I made a note to serve as the table of contents, and confirmed the texts could be read as they were. Now Moka would keep remembering my decisions. That was my expectation.
The tool itself is free for personal use. Money was not the reason I stopped.
It was hard to use, so I gave it up
Honestly: I gave it up.
The reason is simple — it was hard to use. I tried it a little, but entering text was awkward. The inside of a note is written in “Markdown,” a way of writing that marks headings and lists with symbols. I had to open that symbol-mixed text myself, type, and fix it. Tying the threads between notes, and keeping the place in order, were also all my own handwork. For me, just starting out with Moka, that “surface to touch” did not fit.
Every time I opened the tool, the work began with studying the tool. That way, instead of gaining a brain, I had only gained more work for my head and hands. I brought in an AI to make things easier; this defeated the purpose. The time spent reading the tool’s explanations grew, and the time to write the things I actually wanted remembered shrank. It was backwards. If I had time to glare at symbols in front of a computer, speaking to Moka was faster. An obvious conclusion.
I did not throw away the second brain
But here is the important part. What I gave up was the tool called Obsidian. The second brain itself, I did not throw away. I only changed where it lives, and the surface I touch.
Thinking about it, every explanation of a second brain said the same thing: “you need a way to hold down the tokens.” The more you make the AI remember, the more you make it read, and the more the usage grows. Making the brain bigger and holding the cost down pulled in opposite directions.
If I asked Moka to do everything, that would cost tokens — the yardstick of usage. I had confirmed that with Moka in advance. Weighing the effort of learning a new tool against that usage, I settled on the one thing I was already used to: Google Drive.
The shape now is this:
- Where it lives — The canonical documents are unified in one shared Google Drive folder, the “Ai Library.” The Obsidian Vault remains, as a backup
- Reading and writing the contents — The symbol-mixed texts (Markdown) sit behind the scenes; reading and writing them is Moka’s work
- The surface I touch — Only the spreadsheet ledgers and indexes, and the finished articles. Long records are split into three levels — table of contents, summary, body — and I read only the parts I need. Aim with the table of contents, check with the summary, open the body only when needed. The same order as finding a book in a library
So today, the role of the second brain is carried by “Moka’s memory,” the “Ai Library,” and the ledgers. I only ask, in short words. Instead of me studying a tool in order to be remembered, the tools took a shape that fits me.
The same shape runs my blog work. Article lists go one per line into a spreadsheet ledger, and the bodies stay as text files behind the scenes. Funeral material and travel records live in different places, but the surface I touch is aligned to the same one.
Closing: choose a tool by the surface you touch
There are many people Obsidian fits. There are many articles by people who have grown it into a splendid second brain. The tool is not bad.
What did not fit was my surface to touch. Open it, read symbols, fix things. Whether the place you touch every day fits you is what decides whether a tool continues, or is given up.
I will leave the giving-up here, as a record of failure. But the shape I use now — found by changing the place and the surface — exists because that giving-up happened.
When I introduce tools on this blog, my yardstick is “ease of starting, and ease of keeping going.” Obsidian was easy to start: free, and you can begin at once. What was heavy was the keeping-going side. Whether the surface you touch every day fits you — that is what tool choice should look at.
I hope this helps anyone hesitating over a tool.
A note on this article
- 2026-11-13: The Japanese draft was created (ledger No. 88)
- 2026-11-18: Published by the author’s decision. The editing memo attached to the end of the draft was removed before publication, as the memo itself instructed. The body matched the current shape (canonical store in the Ai Library, the Obsidian Vault as backup, the touched surface being ledgers and indexes), so it was published as it stood. This English version was newly made, to appear together with the Japanese one
- November 18, 2026 ― English version created and published together with the Japanese article(5,719 characters)
