The Same Hall, a Different Price Depending on Where You Apply — Rewriting the 2013 'Dual Pricing Problem,' Checked Again
The result first: at the same hall, even for the same funeral, the price can change depending on the window where you apply — online, through a mutual aid association, or directly at the hall. That was the “dual pricing problem” pointed out in 2013, when Uniquest Online, the operator of the low-price online funeral service “Chiisana Ososhiki” (Small Funerals), became a subsidiary of Alpha Club Musashino, a major ceremonial mutual aid association. My original article had three points to correct: the acquisition was not secret (the Nikkei also reported it), I had taken the meaning of “dual pricing” wrongly partway through, and the acquisition amount has never been officially published. A court later accepted the existence of the price difference itself as a fact (without judging it illegal). This rewrite keeps only what published materials support, and separates it from my own view as a former funeral worker.
I am Kurashiki Bouzu (kurashiki-bouzu), a former funeral home owner.
Even at the same hall, even for the same funeral, the price can change just because the window where you apply is different. In 2013, in the funeral industry, this story became a big controversy.
This is a transplant of an article I wrote in 2013 on my former site “Yuyu Jiteki.” The original headline was a bold one: “A Large Acquisition Quietly Completed in the Funeral Industry — The ‘Dual Pricing Problem’ They Do Not Want Probed.”
However, this time, in transplanting it, when I re-checked the facts against published materials from the courts, the Consumer Affairs Agency, and the Japan Fair Trade Commission, there were three points in my original article that needed correcting. Without hiding them, they are these.
- I wrote “quietly completed,” but the Nihon Keizai Shimbun (Nikkei) also reported it at the time. It was not that much of a secret
- I took the meaning of “dual pricing” wrongly partway through and wrote it that way. I will write the true meaning correctly below
- The acquisition amount has still not been officially published even now. The weekly magazine’s “over one billion yen” figure is only an estimate
I will correct what needs correcting, and rewrite it including how things look now, 13 years on.
What Happened in January 2013
The online funeral service “Chiisana Ososhiki,” which sold low prices and “no additional fees.” Its operating company, Uniquest Online, became a subsidiary of Alpha Club Musashino, a major ceremonial mutual aid association, in January 2013.
A mutual aid association is a system in which you set aside money every month to prepare for a future funeral. Funerals for members who had been saving tended inevitably to come to a high total. Into that, an online funeral service appeared holding up a much lower price, and grew. The mutual aid side bought that company. Weekly Diamond reported this as an acquisition of “water and oil,” and conveyed industry voices saying, “The standard-bearer of low prices may be crushed.”
As for the amount, to repeat: there has been no official announcement. Only the figure that Weekly Diamond estimated, “seen to be over one billion yen,” remains. I will write that down as an estimate being an estimate.
The True Meaning of “Dual Pricing”
This is the biggest mistake in my original article.
The “dual pricing problem” that Weekly Diamond pointed out was not about a gap between the displayed price and the amount finally charged. Rather, it was that even at the same hall, even for a funeral performed by employees of the same company, the price changed depending on the window where you applied.
Chiisana Ososhiki took orders online, and left the actual performance to subcontractor funeral homes nationwide. One of those subcontractors was Alpha Club. So, if you applied to Chiisana Ososhiki in Alpha Club’s area, there were cases where the funeral was held at an Alpha Club hall, by Alpha Club employees. In that case, through the website it could be done for a total of about 700,000 yen with a family funeral plan and such, while contracting directly as a mutual aid member, a mystery survey produced a proposal of 1,880,000 yen.
However, these two figures are not under the same conditions. The 1,880,000 yen was a proposal for a scale of 30 people, including meals and return gifts. If you simply write “more than double,” the number walks on its own. My original article, without writing that reservation, replaced it with a different meaning — “the gap between the displayed price and the charged amount” — and spoke in general terms. That was clearly a mistake. I can only say to readers: I am sorry.
That a Price Difference Existed Was Also Accepted in Court
Afterward, this “price difference” was accepted as a fact in court as well.
The judgment of the Intellectual Property High Court in December 2016. At the hall of a group company in Tochigi Prefecture, for a similar funeral, as a mutual aid member it cost a total of 714,000 yen, while through a Chiisana Ososhiki plan, 584,100 yen was enough. The difference was 129,900 yen. The court stated that “it can be said that a dual pricing problem exists.”
I will write this precisely. This judgment did not judge that “dual pricing is illegal.” What was contested was whether the words and actions of an employee who had left were illegal, and the court accepted the existence of the price difference as a premise fact — that is its position. The lawsuit itself ended with the company’s claims dismissed.
Another “Gap Between Display and Charge” Happened as a Separate Story
Ironically, the problem of “the gap between the displayed price and the amount actually charged,” which I had taken wrongly, also later became real in a different form. However, this is not a story of the acquiring side, but a problem with the displays of Uniquest itself, which operates Chiisana Ososhiki. Writing them mixed together invites misreading, so I will write them separately.
- In December 2018, the Consumer Affairs Agency issued an administrative order under the Act against Unjustifiable Premiums and Misleading Representations. The content was that, while displaying “absolutely no additional fees,” additional fees were in fact charged depending on conditions
- In July 2021, a surcharge payment order of 101.8 million yen was issued over the same display
- In December 2021, the Japan Fair Trade Commission published that it had closed its review of a system of special agreements that fenced in partner funeral homes, because the company side had made improvements such as abolishing the system
The way of displaying has continued to be corrected little by little since then, while receiving requests from consumer organizations. On the current official site, the conditions under which additional costs arise are now written in more detail than before.
Thirteen Years On, What Became of “Chiisana Ososhiki”?
The service that was said to be “perhaps crushed” was not crushed. According to the operating company’s publications, its performance record has exceeded a cumulative 660,000 cases (a figure that includes performance through mediation and re-subcontracting to partners).
Its form also changed. In 2020, it brought a group of funeral homes with its own halls under its umbrella, and in 2025, that group’s halls were unified under the name “Chiisana Ososhiki.” Even at just one company in western Japan, it is written on the company’s official page that there are 138 directly operated halls and 502 employees (as of April 2026). Recruitment of full-time “funeral directors,” who handle funeral proceedings and encoffining, is also posted.
The result of my checking, because I wondered, “Now they should have their own halls and employees, so can they still be called a portal site?”, is this. It is no longer a referral-only site, but the form of leaving performance to partner funeral homes nationwide also still remains in a large proportion. It is a combination of referral and direct operation. The parent company itself also holds funerals under the name “Chiisana Ososhiki.” The structure that in 2013 was called “hard to explain” can also be said to now be out in the open.
Also, according to published materials of the Japan Fair Trade Commission, in the partner form, the amount left after deducting the operating side’s share (in the materials, phrased as “our company fee portion”) from the funeral price the family pays becomes the partner funeral home’s receipt. The specific proportion has not been published.
From here is not published material, but my view as a former funeral worker. The directly operated halls are concentrated in Kansai and urban areas (which overlaps with the base of the performance company acquired originally). To my eyes, it looks like the form of “performing in-house in regions where the numbers work, and in regions where they do not, leaving it to partners and receiving a share per case.” However, I could not find published material stating that regions are chosen by profitability. A view is a view; I will draw the line there.
How I Have Seen the Custom of Referral Fees
From here is not a story of a large company, but a small story of what I saw on the floor.
In the funeral industry, the custom of handing a thank-you to a person who made an introduction has existed as a matter of course since long ago. The other party was not only businesses. It extended to ordinary people as well. My own line is: up to about 1,000 to 3,000 yen, it is, so to speak, the level of cigarette money, and can be settled as “a token of feeling.” But when it reaches the level of tens of thousands of yen, the story changes, and I thought even then, “If so, they should lower the selling price to the family by that amount.”
Between business partners, too, there was the same custom. When I was running my company and brought a work proposal to a new florist or caterer, in many cases the other side would bring up referral fees or a “funeral home price” discount first. Every time, I said, “Please use the regular selling price.”
Taking fresh flowers as an example: suppose something whose regular selling price is 10,000 yen per stand is discounted to 6,000 yen at a “funeral home price.” The difference of 4,000 yen does not disappear somewhere. The physical thing becomes that much poorer. The number of flowers decreases. Moreover, not all of the 6,000 yen is used for flowers. The florist also has costs for the labor of making it, delivery, and containers, and their own shop’s share. Excluding those, what actually goes to the flowers can become, for example, about 5,000 yen. The family has no memory of ordering “6,000 yen of flowers,” yet what arrives is flowers that look even smaller than that.
In my organization of it, the selling price is “the part that remains on the receipt,” and the referral fee is “the part that does not remain on the receipt.” On paper it is clean, but money moves where no trace remains. I think one background of that soil was that, at the time, funeral money could only be paid in cash. I also heard in the industry at the time stories that when the tax office investigated a funeral home, they went to check with partner florists and caterers as well. Money that does not remain on a receipt was probably convenient for taxes too — that is how I see it.
Extreme stories were also possible as a system. If someone died far away and the work for a customer who came back in a coffin was received in cash for about 100,000 yen after deducting the coffin’s cost, the fact that the work was done itself never surfaces. That is because in funeral work, “the number of coffins = the number of jobs.” I also often heard stories that after an old funeral worker died, several million yen in cash was found at home and the family was surprised. Money that cannot be brought into the open could only accumulate, unusable. They were stories that came with the punchline that the person was not the type to go out drinking.
At my company (Dil), in nearby areas and far away alike, we had families telephone the florist directly, without going through the funeral home, for flowers. At that time, there was a caution I always conveyed.
“Please do not say, ‘We are holding a funeral, so please deliver them to our home.’ Please say, ‘It is for a memorial service (hoyo).’”
A family member ordinarily asks, “We are holding a funeral, so please bring flowers.” When they asked that way, every time, without fail, a call would come from the florist to my company, and it became the usual referral story. So I conveyed the phrasing in advance. When a florist read ahead, next they would ask the family, “At which funeral home was the funeral held?”, so I also added, “At that time, please say, ‘We had it done far away.’” Behind a single flower order, there was this small offense and defense — that is the story.
If the Window Differs, the Price Also Differs. Knowing That
The acquisition drama of 13 years ago was an event inside the industry. However, the mechanism itself — “the price changes depending on the window where you apply” — remains even now. Through a website, through a mutual aid association, applying directly at a hall. Even for the same funeral, if the entrance differs, the total can change.
What a family can do to prepare is not difficult. Have the estimate produced as a total for each window. Ask, “What is not included in this plan?” And please keep in a corner of your mind that this is an industry with a part that remains on the receipt, and a part that does not.
I myself worked standing on the side that does not receive referral fees. Whether that is right is for the reader to decide. Still, I think knowing what money is moving behind a price is important material for not thinking, at a funeral, “That was a waste.”
- November 18, 2026 ― English draft created (results-first rewrite of the Japanese article, ledger No. 61). Not published; publication is a separate step.(11,386 characters)
